What Should Happen When a KPI Turns Red?

A KPI escalation process turns red numbers into decisions. See how Saudi and GCC firms set owners, money limits and a 13-week reset so red KPIs get decided.

STABILIZE THE BUSINESS

Mustafa M A

11/21/20265 min read

text
text

Four Red Reviews and Still No Decision

It is the fourth monthly review at Faisal's plastics factory (an illustrative case). The scrap rate, the share of production thrown away because it fails quality checks, is red again. The production manager explains it. Procurement points out that its own number, the purchase price of resin, is green. Everyone agrees to "keep a close eye on it". The meeting moves on.

Nobody in that room did anything wrong by the usual standard. The number was reported, discussed and minuted. But nothing was decided. That is the gap a KPI escalation process exists to close: the agreed path a red number follows from the dashboard to someone with authority to act.

The short answer

What is happening: red KPIs are reported every month, but no rule says who must act, by when, or when the issue moves up a level.

Why it matters: every month a red number waits for a decision is paid for in cash. The cost often lands in a different department from the cause.

What to do first: give every red KPI one named owner, a money size and a decision date. Then run a 13-week reset to make that a habit.

Red Is a Request for a Decision, Not a Grade

Most companies treat a red KPI (key performance indicator, the handful of numbers management watches each month) as a grade on someone's work. The owner is asked to explain. A good explanation ends the discussion.

That is the wrong job for the colour. Red should mean one thing: a decision is now due. The explanation is useful only because it points to options.

The evidence suggests many organisations struggle at exactly this step. In a McKinsey survey published in 2019, with more than 1,200 respondents,, only 20 percent said their organisations excel at decision making. And 61 percent said most of their decision-making time is used ineffectively. A review meeting that discusses the same red number four times is a clear example of that wasted time.

What Four Red Months Cost Faisal

Here is the money behind the scene above. All figures are illustrative.

Faisal's factory sells about SAR 90 million a year and spends about SAR 6 million a month to produce. The target scrap rate is 3 percent. For four months it has run at 6 percent.

Four months ago, procurement switched most product lines to a cheaper grade of resin. It saves 4 percent on about SAR 2.5 million of resin a month. The money bridge, per month, looks like this:

1. Scrap at target: 3% of SAR 6 million = SAR 180,000.

2. Scrap at actual: 6% of SAR 6 million = SAR 360,000, so SAR 180,000 extra.

3. Resin saving: 4% of SAR 2.5 million = SAR 100,000.

4. Net result: about SAR 80,000 a month lost, or SAR 320,000 over the four red reviews.

The procurement KPI looked healthy because it measured price alone. The production KPI looked unhealthy because it carried the consequence. Neither manager owned the link between them.

Test Before You Blame the Resin

A rise in scrap does not prove the resin is the cause. Management should test three other explanations before deciding:

• Worn moulds or machines: if scrap rose on specific machines regardless of resin, maintenance is the likelier cause.

• New or rotated operators: if scrap is concentrated on certain shifts, training is the likelier cause.

• A change in how scrap is counted: if the quality team tightened its checks, part of the rise is real measurement, not real waste.

The test is simple. Split scrap by resin batch, by machine and by shift for the last six months. In Faisal's case, the rise followed the resin across machines and shifts. That is strong evidence, though it still deserves a supplier quality check before the decision is final.

Why Red KPIs Get Stuck Between Departments

Faisal's problem is common. Donald Sull, Rebecca Homkes and Charles Sull surveyed 7,600 managers in 262 companies for a 2015 Harvard Business Review study. Only 9 percent said they could consistently rely on colleagues in other functions. Managers were also three times more likely to miss performance commitments because of weak support from other units than because of their own team's failure.

That finding explains why pressure on the KPI owner rarely works. The production manager cannot change the resin contract. The procurement manager is rewarded for the saving. The red number needs someone who owns both, and in most mid-sized companies that is the general manager.

A KPI escalation process solves this by deciding in advance when a red number leaves its owner's desk and whose desk it moves to.

The 13-Week Reset Plan

Faisal does not need a new dashboard. He needs a rule that turns red into a decision, and 13 weeks of practice until the rule becomes habit.

Weeks 1–2: Put an Owner and a Price on Every Red

List every KPI that has been red in at least one of the last three reviews. Give each one a single named owner and an estimate of what it costs per month in SAR. Sort the list by cost. Faisal's list has nine red KPIs. Scrap is the most expensive.

Weeks 3–4: Write the Escalation Rule

Agree on four steps and write them on one page:

1. Within 48 hours: the owner confirms the red is real and not a data error.

2. Within 7 days: the owner brings the likely cause, its monthly cost and two or three options.

3. After two red reviews: the item moves up one level with a decision request, not an update.

4. Above a money limit: it goes straight to the general manager. Faisal sets his limit at SAR 50,000 a month.

The money limit is a management choice, not a benchmark. Set it at a level where the general manager would want to know within a fortnight.

Weeks 5–8: Run It Live on the Top Three

In each review, red items come first. Each discussion ends with one line in a decision log: what was decided, who acts and by when. Scrap reaches the general manager in week 5. He asks procurement and production to test the old resin on the two products where scrap rose most.

Weeks 9–12: Pair the KPIs That Pull Against Each Other

Fix the design flaw behind the problem. Purchase price is now reported next to the scrap and rework it causes, so procurement sees the full result of its choices. Look for other pairs of this kind, such as sales volume against collection days, or overtime against delivery promises.

Week 13: Review the Process, Not Just the Numbers

Measure the rule itself. How many red KPIs reached a decision within two reviews? How many days, on average, passed from red to decision? Faisal's illustrative result: scrap falls to about 3.5 percent by week 9, and the old resin returns on the sensitive products only. The net monthly loss of about SAR 80,000 becomes a small net gain, because part of the saving is kept where quality held.

Where the 3Ms Business Operating System Fits

In the 3Ms Business Operating System, a red KPI is a signal that enters the monthly decision rhythm. Costing and capacity analysis size it in SAR. Governance decides who owns the next move and when it escalates. The decision is logged, and the next review checks whether the number moved.

Saudi listed companies already have a formal version of this duty. The Capital Market Authority's Corporate Governance Regulations make the board responsible for setting performance indicators and monitoring their implementation and the company's overall performance. Private companies are not bound by that rule, but the principle travels well: someone senior must own what happens after the number turns red.

The Rule Worth Keeping

A dashboard tells you where to look. It cannot decide for you. The real test of a KPI system is not how many numbers it tracks but how fast a red one reaches the person who can change it.

The decision rule: no KPI stays red for two reviews without a named decision-maker and a date.

Related reading: why slow collections are more than a finance problem, which pricing KPIs give early margin signals, and how a business consultation sets up your escalation rules.

Sources

• Decision making in the age of urgency, McKinsey & Company, 2019

• Why Strategy Execution Unravels—and What to Do About It, Harvard Business Review, 2015

• Corporate Governance Regulations (amended January 2023), Capital Market Authority, Saudi Arabia, 2023

© 2026 3Ms Business Consulting. All rights reserved.

Product costing, pricing and the 3Ms Business Operating System for Saudi and GCC businesses.

Contact

Three questions to answer before the call

  1. How do you allocate overhead across machines today?

  2. Do you see profit by customer?

  3. Do you track net price after discounts, rebates, freight and terms?

If any answer is "not really", margin is probably leaking, and the Check will show where.